Patrick Noonan Defends Man Caught Jogging Without Pants (Fox 25 News Video)


Lawyer says lewd behavior charge is too much for man caught without pants

by: Robert Goulston Updated: Jun 7, 2016 – 7:25 PM

Also in the news about this case:

Is public nudity lewd is no one sees it? Hingham judge says no 

August 2, 2016 by Neal Simpson, The Patriot Ledger via The Enterprise.

Excerpt:  “The law requires that the person expose himself to a person – that there be a person present to see it,” Noonan told the Ledger. “What we have here is an inanimate object – a camera – and no human being there to see it.”  “Judge Bradley agreed…”  Read Article on the Web

Our Taunton defense attorneys can help you avoid jail time.CASE UPDATE / RESULTS

June 7, 2016
Commonwealth v. Allen Costa
Docket No.: 1658 CR 0507


A woman approached Hanover Police Officers at Forge Pond Park and reported two incidents where she observed a man walking on the trail and the man was naked from the waist down. The woman provided police with a physical description of the male suspect. The police placed a trail camera in the area where the witness reported seeing the male naked from the waist down. According to the police report, the camera showed a male party (matching the witness’s description) walking on the trail wearing no pants on two separate occasions on 03/28/16 and 03/30/16. Subsequently, police conducted a stakeout where they hid in the woods in the area where the male party was seen walking naked from the waist down. According to the police report, one officer observed a male party (later identified as the defendant) walking on the trail wearing no pants or underwear with his penis and testicles completely exposed and the male suspect was swinging his penis side to side with his right hand. The officers emerged from the woods and arrested the Defendant at gun point. At the police station, officers showed the defendant two pictures from the trail camera and the defendant acknowledged that he was the person depicted in the photos. The police charged the defendant with 3 counts of Open and Gross Lewdness. Two of the charges stemmed from the two separate occasions where the trail camera showed the defendant naked from the waist down on 03/28/16 and 03/30/16.

Result: Attorney Patrick J. Noonan filed a Motion to Dismiss the two counts that were based on the camera footage of 03/28/16 and 03/30/16. Attorney Noonan argued that the offense of Open and Gross Lewdness requires that the defendant “expose his genitals to one or more persons” and the law requires that the illegal conduct occur “in the presence of another person.” Attorney Noonan argued that the two charges should be dismissed because there were no human being(s) present to observe the illegal conduct. Attorney Noonan argued that the only witness to the alleged offenses on 03/28/16 and 03/30/16 was the trail camera (an inanimate object) and not a human being. The Judge agreed with Attorney Noonan’s argument and dismissed the two counts that were based on the camera footage.

Experienced Massachusetts Criminal Defense Attorneys

Boston Criminal Defense Attorneys for Criminal Appeals and New Trials

If you have been charged with any type of crime, or are currently under investigation by law enforcement, we want to hear your side of the story.  Call our Massachusetts law offices today at (508) 584-6955 for your free legal consultation.

Our Reputation Speaks for Itself – View Our Case Results

Our Massachusetts Domestic Battery Lawyer represents residents of Plymouth County including Brockton, Plymouth, Bridgewater, Marshfield, Hingham, Duxbury, Scituate, Hanover, Wareham, Abington, Rockland, Whitman, Hanson, Holbrook, Kingston, Middleborough; Norfolk County including Quincy, Stoughton, Dedham, Weymouth, Braintree, Avon, Holbrook, Randolph, Canton, Sharon, Brookline, Franklin; Bristol County including New Bedford, Fall River, Taunton, Attleboro, Dartmouth, Westport, Mansfield, Easton, Raynham, Lakeville, Norton; Cape Cod, Falmouth, Barnstable.



Related posts:

Medical Marijuana Laws Passed in Massachusetts
In November 2012, Massachusetts voters made the state the seventeenth to legalize medical marijuana for patients with cancer, Parkinson’s Disease...
Jury deliberations begin in Brockton murder case
BROCKTON – A jury was unable to come to a verdict Wednesday in a Brockton murder trial where a man is accused of killing a witness in 2010 who wa...
Jury to begin deliberations in Brockton shooting trial
(1993) BROCKTON - Jury deliberations were scheduled to begin today in Brockton Superior Court in the trial of three men accused of shooting a cit...
Charging drug dealers with OD deaths difficult, not impossible
WAREHAM – Last week, Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz’s office announced they had charged an alleged drug dealer in the heroin over...
Trial opens in Brockton for ex-firefighter charged with assaulting late wife
BROCKTON – Stephanie Deeley still has the last voicemail her sister Kimberly Parker left on her cell phone from the day she died in 2013. The me...
Attorney Patrick Noonan Helps College Student in High Profile Case Involving Young Girl Being Pushed...
At a clerk’s hearing, Attorney Patrick J. Noonan persuaded the police prosecutor and the clerk-magistrate to hold the case open until his client ...
Ignition Interlock Device Violation / Rolling Re-Test Violations
An ignition interlock violation committed by someone with a hardship license will result in a revoked hardship license for the balance of the rem...
Patrick Noonan Proves His Client’s Innocence And Wins Not Guilty Verdicts In Drive-by Shooting
In a rare case where a defendant confesses to a crime on social media, attorney Patrick J. Noonan proves his client’s innocence and wins not guilt...